Famous Famiglia Information

If you're wandering through the Upper East Side and craving a slice of pizza that feels like home, Famous Famiglia is the spot to hit up. Nestled at 1248 Lexington Ave, this diner offers a slice of New York comfort, with a casual vibe that’s perfect for grabbing a quick bite or sitting down for a more leisurely meal. There's something about the classic, no-frills atmosphere that gives it a welcoming, down-to-earth energy, making it a favorite for locals and visitors alike.

Walking into Famous Famiglia, you're greeted by the warm aroma of pizza baking in the oven and the friendly chatter of regulars. The place has a cozy, old-school charm that instantly makes you feel like you're in the right place. The interior isn't fussy, just a nice, simple space with enough seating to keep things comfortable without being overcrowded. The vibe is relaxed, and it’s easy to get lost in a conversation or enjoy a solo meal without feeling rushed.

Of course, what really shines here is the food. The pizza, a true New York staple, is the star of the show. Whether you’re a fan of thin-crust perfection or prefer something a little thicker, Famous Famiglia has something for everyone. The crust is crispy but not too hard, with a perfect amount of chewiness to balance the fresh, tangy tomato sauce and gooey cheese. You can’t go wrong with the classic Margherita, but they also have a variety of toppings if you’re in the mood to customize. The pepperoni pizza is another popular choice, with crispy, flavorful slices that add an extra punch of flavor.

Beyond pizza, the menu features a range of Italian-American favorites. From hearty pasta dishes to crispy calzones, there’s no shortage of comfort food here. The spaghetti with meatballs is a classic that won’t disappoint, with the meatballs being tender and flavorful, and the sauce rich and satisfying. If you're in the mood for something lighter, the salads are fresh and vibrant, offering a great balance to the heavier dishes.

One of the things that sets Famous Famiglia apart is the service. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive, always making sure you're taken care of without hovering. They strike that perfect balance of making you feel like a regular, even if it’s your first visit. The vibe is casual, but you never feel like you're being ignored, which adds to the overall enjoyable dining experience.

The location also plays a huge part in its appeal. Situated in a bustling part of the Upper East Side, it’s a great place to stop by after a day of shopping, visiting nearby museums, or just strolling around the city. Whether you’re here for a quick slice on the go or sitting down for a full meal, it offers a great taste of New York without the hassle of waiting in line at some of the city’s more tourist-heavy spots.

All in all, Famous Famiglia is a fantastic choice for anyone in the mood for authentic, satisfying Italian food in a relaxed, welcoming setting. Whether you’re a local or just visiting the area, it’s one of those places you’ll want to keep coming back to.

Most Popular Dishes

  • Garlic Knots $2.50

Rolled baked garlic bread.

  • Garlic Knots With Mozzarella $5.00

Rolled baked garlic bread.

  • Mozzarella Sticks $8.50

Mozzarella cheese that has been coated and fried.

  • SIDE RANCH $0.75

2 oz cup

  • Side Marinara Sauce $0.50

2oz

  • Wings Hot Or Bbq $10.00
  • Sicilian Style Pizza $24.95

Thick, airy crust with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella, baked with a crispy edge. Customize with your favorite toppings!

  • Grandma Denso Pepperoni Pizza $31.95

Thick house cut pepperoni cup and char, fresh mozzarella and sauce.

Open Times

Monday Closed

Tuesday Closed

Wednesday Closed

Thursday Closed

Friday Closed

Saturday Closed

Sunday Closed

Icon

Location & Contact

Contact Details

  • 1248 Lexington Ave #2012, New York, NY 10028, United States
  • Right Now :
  • +1 212-737-7777

What People's Say About Place

Amazing pizza and garlic knots. Tons of choices. Kicking myself I didn't get a chicken wing slice. Clean facility, prompt service, and the staff immediately addressed someone that entered the establishment and tried to panhandle the patrons. Was only visiting the city and glad the family stopped here. Slices are large, prices are very reasonable. The locals are fortunate. Don't let my photo discourage you, I'm a terrible food photographer.

I got a slice of cheese pizza. It was $3.95 for a slice. The ratio of cheese to sauce was great. The flavor of the cheese is excellent. There are so many places where the cheese flavor just isn't strong enough. The sauce is very good. The crust was thin and light. It wasn't very crisp though, which is what it is, and tasted a bit on the bland side, but there were little bits on the back that had a nice slight char flavor. There's indoor seating here which is another plus. Overall I think this pizza is great and certainly worth trying if you're in the area.

What a Gem! Unbelievable how great this spot is. I was there on New Year’s Eve. Everything we ate was amazing. It’s a MUST. Definitely be back.

Our pizza was amazing. Can’t remember what the one was called that had the balsamic vinegar on it but wow. One of the best I’ve ever had. Slightly crunchy crispy bottom, enough bread to satisfy, but not overwhelmed, and the white cheese on the top was the perfect consistency… Not chewy but absolutely bursting with flavor. I’m literally thinking of going back there again today. ;-)

Pizza was good, but I wanted to highlight the customer service. The guys behind the counter were very very nice and patient, and when I asked for a free cup for water with my meal, I was given a regular-size water cup filled with water. In an era of cutting corners to save money, I really appreciate companies and stores that take care to provide customers with a good experience.

Exceptionally delicious pizza! The price is $3.75 a plain cheese slice (Jan 2023). The plain slice pizza crust is very thin for a NYC slice, so if you’re use to filling up on 2 slices- you will need 3! The pizza is satisfying and worth the trip. The counter staff are college age guys with no customer service common sense, so I’m constantly being served by obnoxious people who act annoyed and are very rude (except the cashier). I would have given the place a higher rating but honestly it’s just a bit uncomfortable going into the place.

This has been our happy neighborhood pizzeria ever since MiMi’s closed. Run by a crew of all-smiling Albanian crew, faleminderit! The best authentic NYC slice bo doubt. Kids cant enough of their calzones and Sicilians!

I love this place I stop here every time I’m in the neighborhood. Classic New York pizza and all the guys are cute. The sauce is not too tangy and not too sweet, you can always get a great fold, and it’s not limp. It’s the perfect walking slice.

Places Nearby